Skip to main content

As Philae drifts further from the Sun, scientists fear the lander is asleep for good

After a botched attempt to nudge the European Space Agency’s Philae lander awake last weekend, scientists at the DLR German Aerospace Center say it’s highly unlikely they’ll ever be able to contact the probe again. Though all is not completely lost (today, DLR asked Philae’s companion Rosetta spacecraft to search for signs of the probe’s movements), Comet 67P continues to fly further from the Sun, thus decreasing the chances for Philae to recharge its solar-powered batteries. As Rosetta monitors Comet 67P, the hope is the craft will have the ability to detect a dust cloud indicating Philae received the command and successfully changed its position.

With temperatures rapidly falling on Comet 67P, DLR’s last ditch attempt also utilized the Rosetta spacecraft of which it sent a blind command to the Philae lander to attempt to start its momentum wheel. During Philae’s original attempt at landing on the comet in November of 2014, the momentum wheel was used to guarantee the probe’s stability. Since it bounced around during the landing and finally rested in a particularly inopportune position, the DLR believe this same wheel now has the ability to dramatically shift Philae’s current position.

Recommended Videos

“At best, the spacecraft might shake dust from its solar panels and better align itself with the Sun,” Philae’s technical manager Koen Geurts explains.

Comet 67P
Comet 67P European Space Agency

Clearly, the emphasis is placed squarely on at best considering little is known of the actual state of the probe since it briefly checked in with Earth last June and July. Unfortunately, members of the DLR team strongly believe that at least one of Philae’s two transmitters, as well as one of its two receivers, have since failed. Because of this, the other receiver and transmitter are, according to DLR, unable to continue to “function smoothly.” Moreover, while scientists hope the lander isn’t completely gone for good, they acknowledge its perch on a comet puts it in a precarious position, susceptible to dust and gas.

“Time is running out, so we want to explore all possibilities,” says Philae lander manager Stephan Ulamac. “Unfortunately, Philae’s silence does not bode well.”

Photo of Philae's landing spot
Photo of Philae’s landing spot European Space Agency

Once the month of January ends, it’s reported that Comet 67P will be more than 186.4 million miles away from the Sun. Additionally, this massive distance from the sun will result in an operating temperature of roughly -60 degrees Fahrenheit, thus making it practically impossible for Philae to ever have the ability to turn on again. Despite all signs pointing to a bleak and frigid demise for Philae, the Philae crew on Earth intends to keep Rosetta’s communication unit turned on beyond January.

Unless Rosetta’s cameras catch a miraculous cloud of dust, the DLR and European Space Agency will likely have to be patient until summer to get another crack at what’s going on with Philae. At this time, Rosetta’s orbit will bring the spacecraft close enough for it to capture the best photos of the comet’s surface to date. Not only does the prospect of high-resolution photos give scientists the ability to check in on Philae, but it allows them to learn even more about Comet 67P than ever before.

Rick Stella
Associate Editor, Outdoor
Rick became enamored with technology the moment his parents got him an original NES for Christmas in 1991. And as they say…
Many hybrids rank as most reliable of all vehicles, Consumer Reports finds
many hybrids rank as most reliable of all vehicles evs progress consumer reports cr tout cars 0224

For the U.S. auto industry, if not the global one, 2024 kicked off with media headlines celebrating the "renaissance" of hybrid vehicles. This came as many drivers embraced a practical, midway approach rather than completely abandoning gas-powered vehicles in favor of fully electric ones.

Now that the year is about to end, and the future of tax incentives supporting electric vehicle (EV) purchases is highly uncertain, it seems the hybrid renaissance still has many bright days ahead. Automakers have heard consumer demands and worked on improving the quality and reliability of hybrid vehicles, according to the Consumer Reports (CR) year-end survey.

Read more
U.S. EVs will get universal plug and charge access in 2025
u s evs will get universal plug charge access in 2025 ev car to charging station power cable plugged shutterstock 1650839656

And then, it all came together.

Finding an adequate, accessible, and available charging station; charging up; and paying for the service before hitting the road have all been far from a seamless experience for many drivers of electric vehicles (EVs) in the U.S.

Read more
Rivian tops owner satisfaction survey, ahead of BMW and Tesla
The front three-quarter view of a 2022 Rivian against a rocky backdrop.

Can the same vehicle brand sit both at the bottom of owner ratings in terms of reliability and at the top in terms of overall owner satisfaction? When that brand is Rivian, the answer is a resonant yes.

Rivian ranked number one in satisfaction for the second year in a row, with owners especially giving their R1S and R1T electric vehicle (EV) high marks in terms of comfort, speed, drivability, and ease of use, according to the latest Consumer Reports (CR) owner satisfaction survey.

Read more