Skip to main content

Wanderstop review: cozy tea shop game embraces its flaws

Alta operates a tea machine in Wanderstop.
Annapurna Interactive
Wanderstop
“Wanderstop is a sincere tea shop management game that embraces its imperfections.”
Pros
  • Sincere storytelling
  • Excellent characters
  • Often hilarious
  • Lovely aesthetics
Cons
  • Corny at times
  • Underwhelming puzzles
  • Unsatisfying farming

In 2017, I bottomed out.

Recommended Videos

I had just spent a year fighting to push back a spreading political ideology that threatened to hurt my loved ones and countless more. Every day felt like a battle against a rising tide of hatred. The constant effort culminated in crushing defeat at the ballot box. By the time January rolled around, I was despondent. There was no fight left in me and it felt like there never would be again.

It’s that familiar burnout that plagues Alta, the relatable star of Wanderstop. The debut game from Ivy Road follows a once-undefeated warrior who falls into a downward spiral after finally losing a fight. Her despair and self-doubt take her to a magical tea shop where she’s forced to learn the same lessons I too would come to internalize during my own rebuilding phase. You can’t win every fight, and you certainly won’t keep winning if you never stop to recover between fights. Legacies aren’t just built on wins, but the way we grow from the losses.

It’s a fitting takeaway for Wanderstop, a debut that’s far from a total victory. Its limited shop management and puzzle systems make for a cozy game that never quite finds its footing. What it lacks in complexity, though, it makes up for in spirit and sincerity. It’s an impactful bit of storytelling that embraces the idea that not every game needs to be a masterpiece. Sometimes just planting a seed is enough.

Alta’s odyssey

While Wanderstop presents itself as a cozy tea shop management game, it’s a narrative adventure first. After running through the woods in a panic, Alta wakes up in a clearing. She’s greeted by Boro, a gentle barista who runs a local tea shop in the middle of nowhere. His shop, Wanderstop, is a magical pit stop for passing warriors like Alta to rest. Boro suggests that Alta stay a while and help out with the shop, an offer she begrudgingly accepts as she’s now unable to lift her treasured sword. That premise kicks off an existential therapy session, as Alta confronts the parts of her personality that force her to fight when she has nothing left in the tank.

That introspective story largely works thanks to Davey Wreden’s sharp script. That should come as no surprise considering Wreden’s work on The Stanley Parable and its sensational pseudo-sequel. What is surprising, though, is how different his writing is here. If you’re waiting for some ironic meta twist in Wanderstop, you won’t find one. Wreden instead writes Alta’s tale with sincerity, painting a real picture of burnout through a fantasy heroine. Her anxiety spiral is familiar; she’s convinced that she is only defined by her victories. The idea of taking a moment to reset may as well be a death sentence to her. I wish I couldn’t see myself in Alta, but I certainly do.

Wanderstop never lets go of its heart, even in its silliest moments.

Wanderstop doesn’t just embrace slowing down; it sees it as a necessity to survive. Alta’s growth over the story comes as she learns to sit down and smell the tea leaves. Slow tasks like filling up a watering can or planting seeds become a much-needed reprieve from her fast-paced life of violence. It’s only through rest that she can regain the energy needed to fight another day. Ivy Road isn’t just making a cozy game to capitalize on a trend: The studio is in actual conversation with the genre. It turns the stress-free joys of games like Stardew Valley into a statement on mental recovery. Sometimes it’s all a little corny, with platitudes that sound like they were pulled from self-help books, but it’s always earnest in its approach.

Wreden doesn’t entirely throw out what he’s done so well throughout his career. Wanderstop still delivers some delightfully funny moments between bouts of existential eccentricity. That doesn’t just come out in Alta, whose brash nature and dry wit make her the perfect annoyed barista, but in her customers too. The story is split into specific chunks where two or three people wander around the small clearing surrounding the shop at once. Each one has their own multi-step story that’s progressed by filling their orders and talking to them. That allows Ivy Road to create a fully fleshed out cast of characters rather than a rotating door of nameless people to be served.

Those individual stories are often hilarious. In one section, a rival merchant sets up shop on my clearing and aggressively challenges Alta to an economic war. Later, a gaggle of businessmen start robotically milling around in search for a place where they can present meaningless graphs about financial growth. Wreden even pumps his signature humor into a series of readable noir novels that mount in absurdity with each new volume. There’s a sense of a wider world outside of Alta’s bubble, a bizarre one filled with all sorts of weirdos who are, somehow, making it work.

Alta talks to a knight in Wanderstop.
Annapurna Interactive

But Wanderstop never lets go of its heart, even in its silliest moments. In fact, its most ridiculous characters often fuel the story’s most emotionally impactful scenes. Alta’s relationship with a hyperactive child sets off a key moment of self-reflection that brings the entire tale home. Even now, their final moments together still linger with me. There’s a real sense that Alta has grown by the end of her story and much of that comes from seeing different facets of her reflected in others.

Wanderstop is a call for empathy, something that’s become unfortunately radical in the years since my mental break. It asks players to let down their defenses — even if just for a brief moment — and observe the world with a warm cup of tea in hand. It’s often through understanding others, their problems and all, that we can meet the strangers that live in our own heads.

Limited management

While its writing is strong, Wanderstop struggles to crack the cozy genre. That comes as no surprise. When I chatted with Wreden about the project in December, he noted that he underestimated just how complex a management game like this really is when he conceptualized the project. While its comforting pastel aesthetic and calming music hits the mark, I can see that struggle play out in a wealth of half-realized ideas that don’t fully pay off by the end.

On its surface, the hook should be simple. Players need to run a tea shop and manage the land around it. Necessary tasks include harvesting tea leaves and mushrooms from the clearing surrounding the shop, growing fruits that can be infused in teas, serving customers, washing dirty mugs, and more. Alta gets a few tools to help her with her daily tasks, like weed clippers and a broom to sweep up dirt clumps. The hook is easy to grasp early on as I make my tea balls, create a system of ingredient-rich hybrid plants by planting colorful seeds in specific patterns, and working a giant tea infuser in the shop, which is operated via a sequence of short steps.

Alta plants flowers in Wanderstop.
Annapurna Interactive

What I quickly realize is that Wanderstop is more of a puzzle game than a management sim, and those two ideas often clash. There’s no actual need for me to create a functional farm full of plants. During the story, I only get a series of specific drink requests tied to the few characters who come to rest. There’s no reason to experiment; I just have to plant specific fruit trees needed to fulfill those orders. I need to use my trusty field guide to figure out the flavor of each fruit and the correct seed pattern needed to grow the plant, but that’s largely where the puzzle depth ends. I’m usually just shuffling four colors of seed into two different patterns, completing the same tea machine mini game sequence, and dropping the specified fruits in.

Later orders are a bit more complex, requiring me to use mushrooms to color swap fruits or only add a certain amount of heat to the mix, but Wanderstop ends just as it’s getting creative with the loop. I’m left with a repetitive set of puzzles and not much to do outside of their restrictive demands. The only other benefit to making tea is that I can drink it to unlock a memory tied to each flavor, giving me more insight into Alta’s past.

There isn’t actual room to create a farming ecosystem either. The story is split into two hour chunks where Alta deals with a few customers at a time. When that ends, the entire clearing is wiped clean and Alta starts again from scratch. The only progress that remains is any photos Alta has taken and placed around the shop. While there are systems in place that allow players to manage a field of ingredients, doing so is a waste of time. There’s never a scenario where a player will ever need to do it. It feels like a misunderstanding of the genre and why its automation loops are built the way they are.

Sometimes it’s okay to just be okay at something.

While my instinct is to paint these design quirks as flaws, Wanderstop often has an answer for its decisions. Boro isn’t just a mentor for Alta, but a voice of reason for frustrated players. He encourages me to embrace the repetition of its tea making system, finding value in a routine I can master. When I first learned that my field would wipe every few hours, he was there to remind me that I shouldn’t be afraid of impermanence. It’s all just part of life.

While Wanderstop isn’t meta in the way The Stanley Parable: Ultra Deluxe is, there’s a key moment of self-reflection in it for Ivy Road. Boro’s greatest bit of wisdom is that sometimes it’s okay to just be okay at something. Alta doesn’t need to be the best warrior in the world. She can be a fine one and still have value. All that really matters is that she’s earnestly trying her best. That’s a fitting theme for a cozy game that doesn’t fully nail down the management sim genre. Even when it feels lacking, its heart is always in the right place and it’s more than willing to put the effort in.

In its own way, Wanderstop is the perfect mission statement for a bright-eyed studio starting its path to self-discovery. It is a sincere celebration of our struggles and imperfections. They are not problems to run away from, but stones to sharpen our blades upon so we may win the next fight.

Wanderstop was tested on PC and Steam Deck OLED with a code provided by the publisher.

Giovanni Colantonio
As Digital Trends' Senior Gaming Editor, Giovanni Colantonio oversees all things video games at Digital Trends. As a veteran…
Where to find the cartographer in Emerald Stair in Avowed
Environmental shot of Galawains Tusks Slumbering Fields in Avowed.

You will probably have a good grip on all the tips and tricks needed to beat Avowed by the time you reach the second zone, Emerald Stair. However, no matter how many abilities you have or how good your gear is, finding a missing person with just a vague hint never gets any easier. We already helped Sanza find a missing cartographer in Dawntrail, but he has lost another in Emerald Stair and needs us to track them down. Like last time, the Avowed won't tell you where to go so we explored the entire region to show you exactly where to track them down.
Where to find the cartographer in Emerald Stair

The first cartographer quest at least gave you the general direction to find them, but this time we are only given the name of the area within Emerald Stair. The area in question is called Naku Tedek and is the isolated island on the south end of the map.

Read more
3 PlayStation Plus games to play this weekend (March 14-16)
The PC version of Ghost of Tsushima Director's Cut.

The beginning of March was light in upcoming PS5 games, but the long-delayed Assassin's Creed Shadows is right around the corner. But we still have an entire weekend to fill before it comes out, which is where your PlayStation Plus subscription pays off. The Essential games for March were incredibly strong, but the back catalogue of Extra and Premium games has the perfect selection to get you excited for all the biggest upcoming video games, like Death Stranding 2. Or, it could be the perfect way to find a fun, bite-sized game to hold you over until next week's releases hit and dominate your time. As always, I have hand-selected only the best games in PlayStation Plus for you to play this weekend.
Ghost of Tsushima: Director's Cut
Ghost of Tsushima Director's Cut - Announcement Trailer | PS5, PS4

Even before Shadows was announced, Ghost of Tsushima was touted as being the Japanese AC game that Ubisoft should have made years ago. While that is a reductive way to frame it, there's no denying there are similarities, and the two will be directly compared. Whether you plan on playing Shadows or not, Ghost is a magnificent game that still boasts some of the best graphics on PS5. Exploring the vibrant island of Tsushima as you follow the wind and animals rather than waypoints gives you a deep appreciation for the world you're fighting for. If you missed out on the Director's Cut content, jumping back in for the Iki Island DLC is perhaps the best part of the experience.

Read more
3 Xbox Game Pass games to play this weekend (March 14-16)
Assassin's Creed Odyssey review

Game Pass serves many functions as a service. Some use it to play the best Xbox Series X games on release, others lean on it between games, and everything in between. One of our favorite ways to take advantage of the massive Game Pass catalog is in preparation for upcoming Xbox Series X games. Whether it be playing previous games in a series to get caught up, or games in a similar genre to get in the mood, Game Pass has what you're looking for. We have our eye on Assassin's Creed Shadows next week just like you, but what about this weekend? Here are the best Xbox Game Pass games to boot up over the break.
Assassin's Creed Odyssey
Assassin's Creed Odyssey: Launch Trailer | Ubisoft [NA]

All the best Assassin's Creed games are on Game Pass, but we feel Odyssey is the best of them since transitioning into RPGs. Historically, this is the earliest game in the timeline, though that doesn't matter much since there are only loose threads connecting the games at this point. What does matter is how vast and enjoyable a world this is to explore. It isn't quite as bloated as Valhalla and will get you back into the groove of parkouring, stealthing, and fighting all over again. The story here is also one of the best in the series if you have the time to go all the way with it. But even just dabbling in it so you don't get burned out before Shadows is a great way to prepare yourself.

Read more