Skip to main content

Amazon Prime Video was the most underrated streaming service in 2023. Here’s why

Jury Duty - Official Trailer | Prime Video

When it comes to streaming services, the options are abundant. That’s why it’s not uncommon for many people to subscribe to multiple streamers that cater to their particular tastes. And while it would be easy to argue that Netflix retained its crown as king of the streamers or that Max was a worthy challenger, for our money, Prime Video was by far the most underrated streaming service in 2023. In fact, a strong argument could be made that Prime Video is the best streamer of 2023. For starters, Prime Video comes with a fringe benefit that none of the other sites can match: Amazon Prime membership, which includes free two-day shipping on almost everything that Amazon has to offer.

Recommended Videos

However, for the sake of this list, our primary points will stick strictly to Prime Video’s content, which offers more than enough reasons to justify a subscription in 2024. It also helps that Prime Video avoided messy PR mistakes like cutting its programs for tax breaks, and it even picked up Merry Little Batman and other projects after Warner Bros. Discovery exiled them from Max. This means that the next mature DC animated series, Batman: Caped Crusader, is coming to Prime Video in 2024. If that’s not enough to get excited about, then keep reading for our reasons why Prime Video was the most underrated streaming service of 2023.

Prime Video has the most movies and TV shows

Rachel Brosnahan opens her arms onstage in The Marvelous Mrs. Maise.
Prime Video

If Prime Video ever comes out and says that it has the largest selection of movie and TV shows, then you should know that this is not an idle boast. The Hollywood Reporter (THR) has confirmed that Prime Video streamed 14,206 movie and TV titles in 2023, which was down from its peak of 16,831 titles in 2021. Regardless, that puts Prime Video far ahead of its nearest rival, Netflix, which only had 6,472 titles in 2023.

Prime Video scored key deals with rival studios

Maverick and Penny looking at each other as if about to kiss in Top Gun: Maverick.
Paramount Pictures

Although Amazon owns MGM, its legacy movie studio only had a small selection of hit films in 2023, including Creed III. One of the key factors of Prime Video’s success this year is that it struck deals with Warner Bros. Pictures, Paramount, and Universal Pictures to bring some of their more recent box office hits to the service.

That’s why Elvis, The Batman, Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves, Top Gun: Maverick, and more were streaming on Prime Video in 2023. Some of those films were only streaming for a short time on Prime Video, but no one can say that Amazon didn’t offer some top titles to its subscribers.

Prime Video’s original series and films were of higher quality

Ben Affleck in Air.
Prime Video

Prime Video didn’t offer as many original TV shows or movies as its rivals did. And it wasn’t immune from a few lemons. For example, Awareness was a shameless knockoff of both The Matrix and Jumper.

Regardless, Prime Video’s highs more than made up for that with acclaimed films like Air, The Burial, Totally Killer, Cassandro, and A Million Miles Away. The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel wrapped up its fifth and final season with flair, cementing its status as one of the best shows of the last decade. And in a year filled with mediocre superhero stories on the big screen and on streaming services, the animated series Invincible returned with a surprise special in the summer before premiering the first four episodes of season 2. Even with only half a season under its belt, Invincible season 2 was the best superhero show of 2023, and it left fans on a very enticing cliffhanger for the season’s remaining episodes in 2024.

Prime Video has NFL coverage

L'Jarius Sneed of the Kansas City Chiefs repositions himself for the next drive.
NFL

Never underestimate the appeal of sports. Many of the streaming services offer live coverage of sporting events, and Peacock has gone overboard with sports coverage of events that the majority of people may not have even realized are actual sports! Other streaming services offer simultaneous coverage of the NFL’s Sunday and Monday night football games. But only Prime Video has Thursday Night Football.

Monday Night Football may be the more prestigious of the NFL’s prime-time options, but just having Thursday Night Football on the roster has made Prime Video a player in a way that few outlets can match. Prime Video has now proven that it can handle America’s favorite sport. So when the time comes, don’t be too shocked if Prime Video makes a play for Major League Baseball and the NBA as well. Those are the logical next steps if Prime Video wants to assert its dominance among sports fans as well.

The Freevee factor

People sit in a jury box in Jury Duty.
Freevee

THR didn’t specify whether it calculated Prime Video’s offerings on Freevee when it came up with the 14,206 figure for the films and TV shows that were streamed in 2023. Either way, having Freevee integrated with Prime Video has greatly expanded the viewing options for both movies and series. This year, that included films like F9: The Fast Saga and otherlegitimate blockbuster hits, as well as some terrific films from yesteryear ,including Escape From New York. Freevee also produced Jury Duty, one of the few reality hoax series that was truly hilarious. It’s also a real contender at this year’s Emmy Awards.

The only catch with Freevee is that the shows and movies are ad-supported. That means viewers have to sit through commercials in order to see their chosen programs. If that’s a deal-breaker, then we’ve got bad news for Amazon subscribers. Prime Video is going to switch to the same ad-supported model in 2024 for subscribers to its base tier. Fans can still opt for an ad-free Prime Video experience if they pay extra. But Freevee will remain free, at least so far. And if we have to watch a few commercials in return for more movies and shows, then it seems like a fair trade.

X-Ray

A screenshot of Totally Killer with the X-Ray experience.
Prime Video

X-Ray is not a new feature for Prime Video, but Amazon refined the experience this year. X-Ray is such a simple idea that it’s amazing that Prime Video’s rivals haven’t copied it yet.

With the click of the X-Ray button, Prime Video subscribers can learn who is appearing in each scene, which characters they’re playing, the name of the songs in the background, and more. There are even occasional bits of trivia that pop up and add additional context to the shows and films. Sometimes, that makes watching Prime Video more fun than your average streamer.

Blair Marnell
Blair Marnell has been an entertainment journalist for over 15 years. His bylines have appeared in Wizard Magazine, Geek…
3 underrated Amazon Prime Video movies you should watch this weekend (February 28 – March 2)
Timothee Chalamet and Amy Ryan in Beautiful Boy.

If you subscribe to Amazon Prime because you love you some free two-day shipping, you might also be aware that you get a nifty side benefit with that subscription. Amazon Prime Video actually has a remarkably deep bench of interesting movies, including plenty that you might never think are worth your time.

We've pulled together three of the most underrated titles available on Prime Video that you can check out this month. From a great rom-com to a gripping thriller, this list should have something for everyone, regardless of how you want to spend a weekend evening.

Read more
5 movies leaving Amazon Prime Video in February 2025 you have to watch
Bradley Cooper in American Sniper lying down with another man, both holding rifles.

Quite a few movies are leaving Amazon Prime Video this month across every genre as licensing expires, and they move to different streaming services or become only available for rental or purchase. Armed with this knowledge, it’s the perfect time to sit back and watch one of these flicks before they’re gone.

From newer movies released in the last five years, like the Christmas comedy The Holdovers, to relatively recent ones like Captain Phillips, and older classics like L.A. Confidential and Boogie Nights, there’s a mix of options you won’t want to miss out on. Here, we’re highlighting five movies leaving Amazon Prime Video in February 2025 that you have to watch before they’re removed from easy access with your subscription.

Read more
3 underrated Amazon Prime Video movies you should watch this weekend (February 21-23)
Michael B. Jordan in Creed

If you've ever found yourself stuck scrolling through a streaming service with no idea what you should actually watch, you should know that you're not alone. Everyone has done this at some point, even as they're simultaneously aware that they're wasting time trying to decide what to watch.
If you'd like to skip that portion of the evening and pull something up you'll definitely enjoy on Amazon Prime Video, we've got you covered. We've pulled together three very different but equally great movies you can enjoy, no matter how much time you have on your hands.
Need more recommendations? Then check out the best new movies to stream this week, as well as the best shows on Netflix, best shows on Hulu, best shows on Amazon Prime Video, and best shows on Disney+.
Jiro Dreams of Sushi (2011)
Jiro Dreams of Sushi now on Netflix! | Netflix
A brilliant, surprisingly simple documentary about an expert craftsperson striving to do their work well, Jiro Dreams of Sushi follows Jiro Ono, a master sushi chef who demands excellence from everyone who works for him. As his son struggles to live up to his father's legacy, Jiro must reckon with his singular devotion to sushi and how it has distorted and warped his life.
At the same time, Jiro Dreams of Sushi gives you plenty of time to appreciate the delicacy and beauty of what Jiro accomplishes, making you think for just a moment that all of his sacrifices might have been worth it.
You can watch Jiro Dreams of Sushi on Amazon Prime Video.
Once Upon a Time in America (1984)
Once Upon a Time in America Trailer
An epic we don't often get today, Once Upon a Time in America tells the sprawling story of a young man living in New York's Lower East Side who slowly rises the ranks of the criminal underworld to become a crime boss.
A story as much about America as it is about its individual characters, the movie nonetheless features two incredible central performances from Robert de Niro and James Woods. As director Sergio Leone's final film, the movie is every bit the closing statement that any director could have hoped for.
You can watch Once Upon a Time in America on Amazon Prime Video.
Creed (2015)
Creed - Official Trailer [HD]
Making a legacy sequel to Rocky sounded like a terrible idea. Thankfully, it turned out to be exactly the opposite. Creed tells the story of Adonis Creed, the child of Apollo Creed, as he wrestles with his legacy and trains for an exhibition fight under the tutelage of Sylvester Stallon's Rocky Balboa.
Directed by Ryan Coogler, the movie is as triumphant as the first Rocky. It might be even more impressively directed. It doesn't defy the franchise's expectations, but it fulfills them so perfectly and features such an incredible central performance from Michael B. Jordan that it feels almost miraculous.
You can watch Creed on Amazon Prime Video. 

Read more