Skip to main content

3 underrated movies you need to watch in September 2024

A woman looks at her sleeping husband in Sleep.
Magnolia Pictures

September signals the beginning of the fall season and with it, the promise of quality movies crowding the multiplex. With less blockbusters like Deadpool & Wolverine and more esoteric fare like Speak No Evil, September is sure to see the release of movies that will be award contenders for next year’s Oscars.

There’s always the threat that some films might go unnoticed. Here at Digital Trends, we’ve rounded up three movies that are hovering under the radar that are worth your time and money.

Recommended Videos

Omni Loop (September 20)

Most time travel stories are, at their heart, wish fulfillment stories. Think Back to the Future, About Time, or even Avengers: Endgame; each film involves one or more people going back in time to correct past wrongs. Their dissatisfaction with the present, with how life has turned out, is the force that drives them, and makes the audience connect with them throughout their journey.

Omni Loop, a new film that premiered at South by Southwest earlier this year, focuses less on the sci-fi part of time travel and more on why its protagonist want to change her life in the first place. Zoya (Mary-Louise Parker) has a good reason: She’s about to die in five days due to a black hole in her chest. With the help of Paula (The Bear‘s Ayo Edebiri), Zoya hopes to solve time travel so she can buy more time to be with her loved ones.

The Substance (September 20)

THE SUBSTANCE | Official Trailer | In Theaters September 20

Everybody wants to be younger … or at least look young. For Elisabeth Sparkle, her future depends on it. She’s just turned 50, and as the star of a once-popular aerobics show, she has to meet unrealistic beauty standards set by her employer and by American culture. After being fired, she becomes desperate and accepts an intriguing offer: inject “The Substance,” a mysterious new medicine that allows her to gain a new, younger body. There’s just one catch: She can only inhabit the body for seven days before she has to switch back. Otherwise, there will be consequences. Is it any surprise that she breaks this one rule?

When it debuted at Cannes in May, The Substance, produced, written, and directed by Revenge’s Caroline Fargeat, caused a sensation with critics and audiences being both impressed and grossed out by the movie’s extreme body horror scenes. As Elizabeth and her younger doppelganger, stars Demi Moore (Ghost) and Margaret Qualley (Poor Things) turn in career-best work, and the movie is guaranteed to be one of the most-talked-about of 2024.

Sleep (September 27)

Sleep - Official Trailer | Lee Sun-kyun, Jung Yu-mi | Directed by Jason Yu

We all do things that bother the ones we live with like leaving the toilet seat up or not making the bed every day. But for the newly married Soo-jin (Jung Yu-mi), she discovers a disturbing habit her husband, Hyeon-soo (Lee Sun-kyun), likes to do every night: sleepwalk. And when Hyeon-soo sleepwalks, he exhibits disturbing behavior like scratching his face until he bleeds and speaking in a weird, guttural voice that says they are not alone in their apartment. Does he have a sleeping disorder? Or is there something more sinister at play here?

Released late last year, Sleep became a sensation in South Korea due to its twisty narrative and almost unbearable tension. Now finally set to premiere in the United States in September, the film has been praised by Parasite director Bong Joon-ho as “the smartest debut film I’ve seen in 10 years.” Even viewing the trailer is enough to make you lose some, you guessed it, sleep.

Jason Struss
Section Editor, Entertainment
Jason Struss joined Digital Trends in 2022 and has never lived to regret it. He is the current Section Editor of the…
3 underrated Netflix movies you should watch this weekend (March 7–9)
Tim Blake Nelson plays a guitar while riding a horse in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs.

The sheer volume of content on Netflix can feel endless and overwhelming—every fan knows there are hidden gems out there, but it's easy to get lost in the mix. While it's always fun to catch up on the latest blockbusters, there are numerous underrated movies on the streamer that are just waiting to be discovered. Despite delivering big on story and originality, these deserving films flew under the radar.
Whether you're in the mood for a quirky indie drama, a darkly comedic Western, or a mind-bending thriller, this list has something to make your weekend binge a memorable one. Sometimes, the best movie experiences happen when cinephiles dive into something genuinely unexpected. So get ready for a one-of-a-kind evening spent alone or with loved ones — you'll be glad you took a chance on these underrated picks!
We also have guides to the best movies on Netflix, the best movies on Hulu, the best movies on Amazon Prime Video, the best movies on Max, and the best movies on Disney+.
The Squid and the Whale (2005)

Noah Baumbach, known for directing the more popular Frances Ha and Marriage Story, tells the story of a dysfunctional family in the criminally underrated The Squid and the Whale. Set in 1980s Brooklyn, the indie comedy-drama revolves around the Berkmans, whose lives change for the worse when parents Bernard (Jeff Daniels) and Joan (Laura Linney) announce their divorce. This negatively affects their sons: 16-year-old Walt (Jesse Eisenberg) and his younger brother, Frank (Owen Kline). The rift between the family worsens when Bernard's pretentious intellectualism and Joan's newfound independence cause even more friction.
Bolstered by a semi-autobiographical lens that draws from Baumbach's own childhood and the efforts of producer Wes Anderson, the 2005 film is unflinching in its tragicomic approach to its story. It's an honest portrayal of the messiness of divorce, fully embracing awkward and unfiltered moments experienced by its unlikable characters. The Squid and the Whale's often quirky and subtle humor may alienate most viewers, but any fan of similar intimate and character-driven portraits of imperfect families should add this one to their watchlist.

Read more
3 rom-coms on Netflix you need to watch in March 2025
Two people stand in a field and walk.

Valentine's Day might have passed, but romance is still a major part of Netflix's movie selection. The romance genre page is home to some of the most popular romance movies of the last 30 years. Notting Hill, Miss Congeniality, Wedding Crashers, and Love, Actually are available to stream on Netflix.
This month, we have three rom-coms to watch on Netflix. Two of them are set in Italy, including the latest Netflix original, La Dolce Villa. The other Italian-set rom-com features an actress for one of the streamer's hit shows of 2024. Our third pick is a fantasy rom-com about childhood best friends who grow apart in their mid-20s.
We also have guides to the best movies to stream this week, the best movies on Netflix, the best movies on Hulu, the best movies on Amazon Prime Video, the best movies on Max, and the best movies on Disney+.
Afterlife of the Party (2021)

Afterlife of the Party is more comedy than romance. It's more of a platonic rom-com where friendship is the relationship at play. Regardless, there are still plenty of laughs with supernatural twists. Cassie (Victoria Justice) and Lisa (Midori Francis) have been best friends since childhood. As they reach their mid-20s, the two girls are complete opposites. Cassie is a social butterfly, while Lisa remains an introvert.
After a night of drinking leads to an argument, a hungover Cassie trips on her walk to the bathroom and hits her head on the toilet. Cassie dies, but she can't get into heaven just yet. She must help three people, including Lisa, in five days or be forced to live in a version of hell called "below." Think of Afterlife of the Party as Ghost without the pottery scene and the murder.

Read more
3 underrated movies on Amazon Prime Video you need to watch in March 2025
Several workers with bags standing in a remote location looking scared in Severance.

What makes a movie underrated? It might be that critics have panned the film even though it has earned massive box office success and positive reception from audiences. Perhaps it’s the other way around, and critics love it, but audiences fail to see what’s so special. Some underrated movies are fantastic but simply didn’t get the attention they deserved and have slipped into the deep depths of streaming services, only to be unearthed by those who dare to find them.
The three underrated movies on Amazon Prime Video you need to watch in March 2025 fall into varying categories that qualify the movies as underrated. One broke records, yet critics refuse to give it two thumbs up. Another shares its name with one of the hottest shows streaming right now.
Need more recommendations? Then check out the best new movies to stream this week, the best movies on Netflix, the best movies on Hulu, the best movies on Amazon Prime Video, the best movies on Max, and the best movies on Disney+.
The Super Mario Bros. Movie (2023)
The Super Mario Bros. Movie | Official Trailer

Even before it premiered, The Super Mario Bros. Movie was getting a lot of flak for the choice of Chris Pratt as the voice of the titular character. Following the debut of this adventure comedy film in theaters, critics still weren’t convinced that it was a hit. But The Super Mario Bros. Movie delighted fans and proved naysayers wrong.
The film explored an interesting dynamic whereby Bowser (Jack Black) was a softie with a deep love for Princess Peach (Anya Taylor-Joy). Of course, this brought us that lovely gem of a Peaches song that kids sang for weeks after. The movie's mixed reviews are no match for its tremendous box office success, not to mention the fact that it broke a Guinness World Record to become the highest-grossing movie based on a video game and became the first movie based on a video game to gross more than $1 billion. It’s incredible to learn that with all these huge numbers, The Super Mario Bros. Movie only has a 59% Rotten Tomatoes critics score.
Watch The Super Mario Bros. Movie on Amazon Prime Video. 
Severance (2006)
Severance (2006) Trailer | Danny Dyer | Laura Harris

Read more