Skip to main content

This underrated Michael Keaton movie is a big Netflix hit. Here’s why you should watch it

Michael Keaton points a gun in American Assassin.
Lionsgate

In 2017, American Assassin only had a short stay at the box office on its way toward a disappointing $67.2 million worldwide gross. That seemingly put an end to any ambitions to turn the late Vince Flynn’s action-thriller novels into a cinematic franchise. But as we’ve seen so many times before, the Netflix effect can change everything. Shortly after its arrival on the platform, American Assassin topped the charts of Netflix’s 10 most popular movies.

American Assassin plays like a throwback to 1980s action flicks, as former Teen Wolf star Dylan O’Brien steps into a leading role as Mitch Rapp. All Mitch wanted to do was enjoy his life with his girlfriend, Katrina Harper (Charlotte Vega). But after Katrina is killed in a terrorist attack, Mitch makes it his personal mission to hunt down the man responsible for her death. That brings Mitch to the attention of CIA Agent Stan Hurley (Michael Keaton), who recruits him to join the black ops unit Orion. Mitch quickly proves that he belongs in the CIA, but his true test lies ahead when a former member of Orion threatens to destabilize the world with a nuclear weapon.

Recommended Videos

If you’ve been on the fence about this action flick, here are three reasons why you should watch American Assassin on Netflix.

Dylan O’Brien shows off his action hero potential

Dylan O'Brien in American Assassin.
Lionsgate

O’Brien hasn’t really gained traction yet as an action hero, which may be because American Assassin didn’t light the box office on fire. But now that the film is a hit on Netflix, audiences can see how O’Brien sheds his teen idol look and actually appears to be fully capable of holding his own in a fight.

Physicality is only part of playing a great action hero. The quality that most would-be action stars lack is the ability to make the audience feel for them. O’Brien’s ability to emote allows viewers to have sympathy for him in his darkest moments, while also allowing them to root for him when he starts kicking terrorist butt around the globe. This wasn’t O’Brien’s breakout role, but it’s the kind of part that may lead him to something bigger in the future.

Michael Keaton delivers a great supporting performance

Michael Keaton in American Assassin.
Lionsgate

Be honest: Have you ever seen Michael Keaton give a bad performance? He’s been in plenty of bad movies like 2023’s The Flash, but Keaton always delivers on his end of the bargain, regardless of the genre. Keaton’s role as Rapp’s mentor could have been a thankless and throwaway part. But somehow, Keaton manages to make his character compelling even during exposition scenes.

The biggest reason why Keaton works so well in this movie is that he is by far the most believable character in the flick, even more so than O’Brien’s Rapp. Everything about Keaton’s performance is convincing, and that goes a long way toward helping the audience buy into the stakes of the film.

Taylor Kitsch’s Ghost is a formidable villain

Taylor Kitsch in American Assassin.
Lionsgate

The funny thing about Taylor Kitsch’s role in this movie is that he was also a teen idol thanks to his stint on NBC’s Friday Night Lights. Like O’Brien, Kitsch had some previous action experience to draw from, including a leading role in the incredibly underrated sci-fi flick John Carter.

American Assassin may be the first time that Kitsch had to play a true villain, and he really goes for the throat as Ghost, an ex-operative of Orion. As far as Ghost is concerned, he’s completely justified in getting his revenge on the CIA. And he’s more than willing to sacrifice his life to get his revenge on his country. Kitsch’s performance and physicality go a long way toward making him a convincing foil to both O’Brien and Keaton in this flick. Kitsch may not get many leading man roles any more, but he’s clearly got a great future as a cinematic bad guy.

Watch American Assassin on Netflix.

Blair Marnell
Blair Marnell has been an entertainment journalist for over 15 years. His bylines have appeared in Wizard Magazine, Geek…
3 underrated Netflix movies you should watch this weekend (February 28-March 2)
Suzume holding a chair in front of a door in the movie.

Sometimes, the best movies aren't the ones trending on your Netflix homepage — they’re the hidden gems waiting to be discovered. Big-budget blockbusters and buzzy originals from the streamer may be the natural first option, but some movie nights call for lesser-known flicks that can pleasantly surprise and captivate any cinephile.
Several great movies are streaming on Netflix that have flown under the radar. Whether you're in the mood for a whimsical anime offering, a cyberpunk story, or a chilling found-footage film, there's something on Netflix's catalog for you. So why not skip the usual picks and dive into something different this weekend? With so many hidden gems on the streamer, you're bound to find a new favorite you'll be recommending to your friends come Monday.
We also have guides to the best movies on Netflix, the best movies on Hulu, the best movies on Amazon Prime Video, the best movies on Max, and the best movies on Disney+.
Suzume (2022)

Suzume is a great anime movie worth streaming from director Makoto Shinkai. It follows the titular 17-year-old protagonist (voiced by Nanoka Hara) as she stumbles upon a mysterious door that stands alone in an abandoned house. She discovers that the door is a gateway to another realm, unwittingly setting off a chain of supernatural events in the process. As the door begins unleashing calamities across Japan, Suzume joins forces with a young stranger, Sōta (Hokuto Matsumura), a "Closer" tasked with sealing these portals. But when Sōta is transformed into a three-legged chair — yes, a literal wooden chair — their journey takes a surreal turn.
Despite its stunning animation and unique storytelling, Suzume remains criminally underrated compared to its predecessors from Shinkai, Your Name and Weathering with You. Perhaps it's because the 2022 film leans more into Japan's historical wounds — referencing the 2011 earthquake and tsunami — making it feel deeply personal for domestic audiences but less immediate for international viewers. Suzume also subverts expectations with its romantic storyline that defies traditional tropes. Those who appreciate its appeal understand that its moving narrative reflects trauma, growth, and all the messiness that comes with it.
Suzume is streaming on Netflix.
Upgrade (2018)

Read more
5 movies leaving Netflix in February 2025 you have to watch now
Mark Wahlberg pulling Will Ferrell's tie in a scene from The Other Guys

Rom-coms aren't the only movies on Netflix in February. Action and thrillers are currently dominating the top 10. To Catch a Killer, Aftermath, Don't Let Go, and Rambo: Last Blood are all in the top eight. If you like romance, Notting Hill, La Dolce Vita, and Miss Congeniality are ready to go.
Movies will be heading out the door with the month winding down. Unfortunately, many of these movies will land on other streaming services you do not have. With the little time you have left in February, carve out some time to watch one or all of these five movies leaving Netflix. Our picks include a Nolan thriller, an underrated comedy, and a Cruise sci-fi adventure.
We also have guides to the best new movies to stream, the best movies on Netflix, the best movies on Hulu, the best movies on Amazon Prime Video, the best movies on Max, and the best movies on Disney+.
Sea of Love (1989)

Al Pacino has a knack for playing a hardened detective. New York City homicide detective Frank Keller (Al Pacino) spends most of his days glued to a bottle of booze to get over his depression. Frank's latest case is to investigate a murder where a man was left in a room with a want ad by his side and the song Sea of Love playing in the background.
As more victims die with the same clues left behind, Frank begins placing ads in the paper to lure the killer into a meeting. Frank gets a hit from Helen Cruger (Ellen Barkin), and the two begin a passionate relationship. The romance turns complicated when Frank considers Helen a suspect. Is Frank willing to look past the evidence in the name of love?

Read more
3 underrated (HBO) Max movies you should watch this weekend (February 21-23)
James Franco stands with his shirt coming off.

HBO is about to dominate Sunday nights again with the return of The White Lotus. Season 3 heads to Thailand for another weeklong vacation. As always, murder isn't too far away. Meanwhile, The Pitt was recently reviewed for a second season on Max. Television remains Max's strong suit.
Don't forget about movies. The Warner Bros. library is one of the deepest of the major studios. Max's vault provides viewers with countless hours of programming — classics, Oscar winners, blockbusters, and franchises. If you're looking for something off the beaten path, try watching some underrated movies, including a hysterical rom-com, a charming dramedy, and an action blockbuster.
We also have guides to the best movies on Netflix, the best movies on Hulu, the best movies on Amazon Prime Video, the best movies on Max, and the best movies on Disney+.
Yes Man (2008)

The world misses Jim Carrey. The Canadian comedy was as A-list as it gets for over 20 years. Now, Carrey only acts in Sonic movies. The only way to experience Carrey's liveliness is to revisit his old movies like the underrated Yes Man. Bank loan officer Carl Allen (Carrey) is in a downward spiral. Carl has failed to recover from his divorce, and his pessimism leads to the dissolution of his friendships.
Desperate for a change, Carl attends a self-help seminar, where he agrees to say yes to anything asked of him. Carl takes this advice quite literally, refusing to say no to any task. Carl's "say yes" attitude leads to a job promotion, a new girlfriend, and a happier outlook on life. Are these happy coincidences, or does Carl truly believe he can never say no? Either way, enjoy Carrey's charisma.

Read more